Banner featuring creatures with colorful eyes

All Products

204 products
Sort by:
Featured
Orange-eyed Bat Pin
50% off
The Bindlewood Shop Orange-eyed Bat Pin is a cute, cartoon enamel pin featuring a chubby bat with round orange eyes, small fangs, upright ears, and black wings on a plain white background.

Orange-eyed Bat Pin

$5
$10
Lemon Bee Pin
50% off
A whimsical, cartoon-style enamel Lemon Bee Pin of a cute "Lemon Bee" character designed by Amanda Louise Spayd, with large eyes and a friendly expression from Bindlewood Shop.

Lemon Bee Pin

$5
$10
Goth Ponycorn Tee
Drawing of a cute, chubby unicorn with big, expressive eyes. The unicorn has a lavender mane and tail, a blue-green horn, and pastel-colored highlights in its hair. Its body is gray with subtle skull patterns, perfect for a Goth Ponycorn Tee from Bindlewood Shop, and it stands on two legs against a light blue background.

Goth Ponycorn Tee

$25—$28
Glittery Albino Bat Pin
50% off
Illustration of a whimsical creature resembling a pink rabbit with bat wings, featuring the Bindlewood Shop Glittery Albino Bat Pin with sparkly pink glitter wings and large, round red eyes. The background is a simple, textured white.

Glittery Albino Bat Pin

$5
$10
Unicorn Suit Sticker
The Unicorn Suit Sticker from Bindlewood Shop features a stuffed, blue-skinned cartoon character with large eyes and a droopy mouth, dressed in a whimsical pink unicorn onesie complete with a horn, ears, mane, and tail. This sticker captures an adorable yet odd appearance that would make for high-quality stick-on decorations.

Unicorn Suit Sticker

$3
Rainy Day Friends Sticker
Rainy Day Friends Sticker design featuring a cheerful sun peeking behind a gloomy, teary-eyed cloud with raindrops falling, illustrated in a cartoon style with bold outlines and a matte finish by Bindlewood Shop.

Rainy Day Friends Sticker

$3
OMGhost Pin Set
The OMGhost Pin Set by Bindlewood Shop features a cute green cartoon character pin with big eyes and a black and white “YES YES PIZZA YES ALWAYS” spirit board-style pin with moon and sun corners, shown on a plain light background.

OMGhost Pin Set

$10
Sparkle Pony Magic Pin
50% off
A cute enamel pin featuring a pink unicorn with a chubby body, large black eyes, and a small, smiling mouth. The Sparkle Pony Magic Pin from Bindlewood Shop showcases a colorful mane and tail with pink and green stripes, glittery sparkles, and a pink heart design on its side. The background is white.

Sparkle Pony Magic Pin

$5
$10
Catstume Pin
50% off
A quirky enamel pin featuring a cartoon-style, stitched-up zombie cat with large, expressive eyes and a vibrant yellow face against a light background, called the Catstume Pin from Bindlewood Shop.

Catstume Pin

$5
$10
Donut Pip Sticker
A blue, wide-eyed Pipsqueak with bunny ears sits in a pink-frosted, sprinkle-topped donut in the Donut Pip Sticker by Bindlewood Shop.

Donut Pip Sticker

$3
Donut Bat Pin
50% off
A hand holds the Bindlewood Shop Donut Bat Pin—an enameled metal pin of a chubby purple bat with yellow eyes, pink ears, and blue wings clutching a bitten pink frosted donut. Blurred foliage fills the background.

Donut Bat Pin

$5
$10
Goth Ponycorn Sticker
Goth Ponycorn Sticker of a cartoonish, chubby unicorn with a skull pattern on its body, designed by Chris Ryniak. It features a whimsical expression and a colorful mane and tail, completed with Bindlewood Shop.

Goth Ponycorn Sticker

$3
MothPup Sticker
The MothPup Sticker from Bindlewood Shop is a cartoon-style vinyl sticker featuring a cute, mint-green bug with big shiny eyes, yellow-pink wings, teal antennae, tiny claws, and a sad expression on its chubby body in a matte finish.

MothPup Sticker

$3
ULTRA MEGA STICKER PACK!
Brighten any space with the ULTRA MEGA STICKER PACK! from Bindlewood Shop—a delightful assortment of colorful vinyl stickers showcasing cute, big-eyed fantasy creatures, whimsical animals, and charming characters with expressive faces, all perfect for adding playful energy to your favorite surfaces.

ULTRA MEGA STICKER PACK!

$150
Threadbear Adoption
A grid of 12 eerie, vintage-style “Threadbear Adoption” stuffed bear dolls by Bindlewood Shop, each wearing a colorful party hat and ruffled collar, featuring large glass eyes and toothy grins in assorted fur colors, all set against retro dotted backgrounds.

Threadbear Adoption

$350
Pizza Spirit Board Magnet
The Pizza Spirit Board Magnet from Bindlewood Shop features a Ouija board-inspired design with sun and moon graphics and the playful phrase, “YES YES PIZZA YES ALWAYS,” making it a perfect match for your favorite colorful acrylic or textured gray refrigerator magnet.

Pizza Spirit Board Magnet

$8
Pizzaboy Magnet
Bring some fun to your fridge with the Pizzaboy Magnet from Bindlewood Shop! This playful magnet features a cartoon slice of pepperoni pizza with large, shiny eyes and a pizza cutter in hand, standing upright against a textured gray background—a vibrant acrylic accessory sure to brighten up any collection.

Pizzaboy Magnet

$8
Donut Pip Magnet
The Donut Pip Magnet by Bindlewood Shop features a pink frosted donut with colorful sprinkles and a blue, bunny-shaped figure with big pink eyes standing in its center, set against a gray background—perfect as a playful acrylic magnet to brighten up your fridge.

Donut Pip Magnet

$8
Mothman Magnet
Add a touch of whimsy to your fridge with the Bindlewood Shop Mothman Magnet—featuring a cartoon depiction of the legendary creature with fluffy gray fur, large glowing red eyes, tiny fangs, short horns, and wide black wings on a textured gray background. Perfect as a novelty decoration or a unique collectible for any Mothman fan!.

Mothman Magnet

$8
All the Cats! Magnet
The All the Cats! Magnet from Bindlewood Shop features an adorable cartoon creature with big eyes and blushing cheeks, surrounded by three cats—a gray one perched on its head, a grumpy blue cat in its lap, and a surprised orange kitty beside it—all set against a shiny gray background for the perfect cat-inspired magnet design.

All the Cats! Magnet

$8